Sign in Subscribe

MARKETED SALE VS DIRECT ACQUISITION: HOW YOU CAN MAXIMIZE VALUE

Last updated on 
Share

Marketed Sale vs Direct Acquisition: How Canadian Businesses Can Maximize Value

When Canadian business owners decide to sell, a pivotal decision involves choosing between a broadly marketed sale and a direct acquisition. The chosen approach can significantly impact the final valuation, experts say.

Marketed Sales: Competition Drives Higher Valuations

A broadly marketed process exposes a business to a wide range of potential buyers, including strategic buyers, private equity firms, and high-net-worth individuals. Often managed through a competitive auction or structured sale by a business broker or investment banker, this approach aims to maximize competition.

Studies and industry insights suggest a well-executed, broadly marketed sale can increase the sale price by 20% to 50%, or more in some cases, compared to a single-buyer scenario. Multiple bidders create urgency, pushing offers higher.

"Competition is a key driver in maximizing business value," said Adam Smith author of The Wealth Of Nations.

Key advantages include:

  • Increased Valuation: Competitive bidding drives up offers.
  • Wider Exposure: Reaching more potential buyers.
  • Stronger Negotiation: Multiple offers enhance leverage.

However, this process requires time and preparation.

Direct Acquisition: Speed and Simplicity, Potential Lower Value

A single-buyer approach, negotiating directly with one party, often a competitor, employee, or partner, typically results in a lower valuation. Without competition, the buyer has more leverage.

Valuations in a direct acquisition might fall 10% to 30% below a marketed process. Advantages include faster closing and reduced disruption.

"While a direct acquisition offers speed and simplicity, it often comes at the cost of a lower valuation," said Karl Sigerist, Managing Director of the Shaughnessy Group. "Unless there are unique synergies, sellers may leave money on the table."

Valuation Examples

Consider a business with $1 million EBITDA. In a single-buyer deal, a 3.75x to 4.25x multiple could yield $3.75 million to $4.25 million. A marketed process might achieve a 5x to 5.75x multiple, resulting in $5 million to $5.75 million or more.

Canadian Market Considerations

The Canadian market's regional and industry variations influence these outcomes. Technology companies in Vancouver or energy businesses in Alberta may attract specific buyers, affecting valuation.